The armenian genocide 191523 was the deliberate and systematic destruction of the armenian population of the ottoman empire during and just after world war i. A disputed genocide utah series in turkish and islamic stud 9780874808902. The armenian genocide historical background and the aftermath of genocide armenians have inhabited their ancestral homeland in the transcaucasus area where europe and asia meet between presentday turkey and russia for nearly 4,000 years. The turkish government currently denies the genocide.
Guenter lewy author of the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. Can you talk a bit about why the turkish government perceived the armenians and assyrians as a threat, and why they chose such an extreme. Armenia and several other nations recognize the deaths to have occurred during an armenian genocide. The armenian genocide was the centrally planned and systematically executed deportation and murder of over 2 million christian armenians, greeks and assyrians by the ottoman turkish government from 19151923. The armenian genocide also known as the armenian holocaust was the systematic mass murder and expulsion of 1. Professional ethics and the denial of armenian genocide pen. A disputed genocide utah series in turkish and islamic studies paperback by guenter lewy, dave schmitt isbn. The significance of the armenian genocide on current affairs cannot be undermined. The starting date is conventionally held to be 24 april 1915, the day that ottoman authorities rounded up, arrested, and deported from. Since 1876, the ottoman government at the time was led by sultan abdul hamid ii. Jan 30, 2015 for almost a hundred years, turkey has disputed the killings and hit back against the use of the armenian genocide label, widely used by armenia and the armenian diaspora. Every year, around this time, there is usually a lot of media activity on the matter that is widely known as the armenian genocide. The armenians of the eastern regions of the empire were systematically massacred. Akcam stated that this was the central thesis of the book with this statement made on several occasions.
Table of contents for the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. I am a turkish american, and on the centenary of the armenian tragedy of 1915, i thought i should write about my views on the issue. Apr 24, 2015 i am a turkish american, and on the centenary of the armenian tragedy of 1915, i thought i should write about my views on the issue. A history of the armenian genocide human rights and crimes against humanity by ronald grigor suny 6 times. Historical background the ottoman empire reached the height of its power in the 16th and 17th centuries, when it grew from a small princedom to become the single most important state in. The book caused a great resonance in both academia and the civic society of armenia and turkey. From the beginning of the reform period after the signing of the berlin treaty, hamid ii attempted to stall their implementation and asserted that armenians did not make up a majority in the provinces and that their claims of abuses were largely exaggerated or false.
In 1915, the ottoman government, then run by the young turks, deported most of its armenian citizens from their eastern anatolian lands. Kennan institute project the armenian genocide, 19151916. Ottoman armenian casualties refers to the number of deaths of ottoman armenian people between 1914 and 1923. It also crops up periodically in other parts of the world when members of the armenian diaspora push for recognition of the armenian genocide by their respective parliaments and the turkish government threatens retaliation. Germany and turkey were allies during world war i, on the opposite side to russia, britain and france. Armenia and turkey are at odds over whether the world war i massacres and deportations of armenians by their ottoman rulers should be described as genocide.
Interview with ronald suny, kennan institute title viii shortterm scholar, and professor of history, university of michigan, on august 11, 2014. Ambassador to the ottoman empire, morgenthau, states that the conditions of the war. Being the first nation to adopt christianity as its state religion in 301 a. On the availability of survivor testimony in the form of oral history, see miller. Apr 14, 2020 in the armenian genocide, the deportations and massacres were often carried out by nomadic kurds, circassians or, cherkess, as theyre also called, chechens many of them refugees from the caucasus or the balkans, so called muhacirs, other refugees who were to be settled in the armenian villages, and ordinary people, even women. Historical background the ottoman empire reached the height of its power in the 16th and 17th centuries, when it grew from a small princedom to become the single most important state in the mediterranean and the near east. Most estimates of related armenian deaths between 1915 and 1918 range from 800,000 to 1. A disputed genocide 2 features norman stones assertion that this book, which has olympian fairmindedness as well as thorough knowledge of the various sources, now.
The armenian massacres in ottoman turkey wikipedia. Jun 02, 2016 the massacres and deportations of 1 million to 1. It is a history that is as relevant today as it was in the 1940s. A disputed genocide is a 2006 book by guenter lewy, published by the university of utah press, about the. Turkey protests germanys recognition of armenian genocide.
According to reliable estimates, close to forty percent of the prewar population perished, many in brutal massacres. He described the armenian massacre of 1915 which took. An armenian odyssey by dawn anahid mackeen 6 times they can live in the desert but nowhere else. The story of the armenian genocide and its legacies is told in facing historys newest resource book, crimes against humanity and civilization. Despite overwhelming documentation by historians and condemnation by over 25 countries worldwide, an unrepentant turkey seeks to both enforce an. Hamidian massacres ottoman and armenian history britannica. While it has undoubtedly made its mark on the armenian people, this genocide has also had further reaching significance. Armenian turkish conflict the events of 1915 defining genocide the events of 1915 reflect a grim and dark time in the history of the. The armenian massacres in ottoman turkey a disputed. Disagreeing with the official version can be interpreted as a crime in turkey, and brings other risks, too. The american response to the armenian genocide facing. Germany helped the ottoman empire to carry out armenian.
Today, most historians call this event a genocidea premeditated and systematic campaign to. A disputed genocide, published by university of utah press. Guenter lewy, the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. Armenians call it the first genocide of the twentieth century. Professor lewy talked about his book the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. Turkey denies 1915 genocide to cover up 1895 armenian. They are generally called the hamidian massacresafter the ottoman sultan abdulhamid ii, during whose reign they were carried outto. Turkey similarly denies the genocides perpetrated against indigenous assyrians and greeks during the same period. In the midst of world war i and as the ottoman empire suffered through what we now know were its last years, turkish officials oversaw the deportation and massacre of anywhere between several. Professional ethics and the denial of armenian genocide.
Many have heard of the armenian genocide, 1915 genocide or. The dust jacket of guenther lewys the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. A bibliography relating to the deportations, massacres, and dispersion of the armenian people, 19151923 cambridge, ma. The armenian massacres in ottoman turkey u of u press. The armenian genocide historical background and the aftermath. The present volume of documents presents testimony of the survivors of the armenian genocide which, on the basis of indisputable facts. Many of the weapons used by the ottoman empire to carry out the armenian genocide were from germany, according to a new report. Collection of documents amatuni virabyan, levon baghdasaryan on. The amount of attention the armenian massacres occupied was significant. Guenter lewy author of the armenian massacres in ottoman. On friday, yerevan and the armenian disapora together with world leaders in the armenian capital will commemorate the 1. Dadrian claimed that islam is a dogma that does not change and that the majority of massacres occurred on fridays after muslim. The armenian massacres in ottoman turkey a disputed genoside.
Apr 24, 2015 on friday, yerevan and the armenian disapora together with world leaders in the armenian capital will commemorate the 1. The work focuses on the armenian genocide during 19151916 and provides no coverage of subsequent years lewy argued that there was not enough evidence to support the conclusion that the ottoman government deliberately attempted to destroy the armenian population through a genocide. Turkey, as the successor state of the ottoman empire, successfully. The armenian massacres in ottoman turkey examines the rich historical evidence without political preconceptions. The veteran scholar of the genocide, sociologist vahakn dadrian, disputed sunys decoupling of the genocide from earlier turkish massacres and his downplay of the significance of islam as a cause of the violence. The armenian massacres in ottoman turkey examines the rich historical. The armenian genocide historical background and the. Utah series in middle east studies in 1915, the ottoman government, then run by the young turks, deported most of its armenian citizens from their eastern.
This book is a translation of a book that was published in the us by the university of utah press in 2005 under the title the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. Project muse the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. Relying on archival materials as well as eyewitness testimony, guenter lewy avoids the sterile wasitgenocideornot debate and presents a detailed account of what actually happened. Hrant dink, an intrepid turkish newspaper editor of armenian extraction, was shot dead. By the early 1920s, when the massacres and deportations finally ended, some 1. Bibliographic record and links to related information available from the library of congress catalog. Guenter lewys the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. For almost a hundred years, turkey has disputed the killings and hit back against the use of the armenian genocide label, widely used by armenia and the armenian diaspora. Guenter lewy is the author of the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey 3. The armenian genocide is almost unanimously acknowledged as a historical fact by historians and. The armenian massacres in ottoman turkey a disputed genocide by guenter lewy 2005, p. Armenian turkish conflict the events of 1915 defining. On april 24, 2015, much of the world will commemorate the centennial of one of the most highly contested events of the twentieth century.
Turkeys erdogan says history will be the judge of the. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. I think its worth noting that the new york times alone ran 145 articles on the armenian massacres just in 1915. Vestnik kavkaza publishes chapters from the book of guenter lewy the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. The accused were found guilty in the judgment of 5 july 1919, of the organization and execution of the crime of massacre against the armenian population. Historiography and the armenian massacres, middle eastern studies, jan. I mean, the coverage of this event was really large given that a world war was going on. Relying on archival materials as well as eyewitness testimony, guenter lewy avoids the sterile wasit genocide ornot debate and presents a detailed account of what actually happened. For an extensive bibliography on the armenian genocide, see richard g. Armenians in the ottoman empire during the nineteenth century.
The highly charged historical dispute burdens relations between turkey and armenia and increases tensions in a volatile region. No armenian genocide 37 turkey, past and future what is genocide. Hamidian massacres, series of atrocities carried out by ottoman forces and kurdish irregulars against the armenians in the ottoman empire between 1894 and 1896. Today, most historians call this event a genocidea premeditated and systematic campaign to exterminate an entire people. Paris afp armenia and turkey are at odds over whether the world war i massacres and deportations of armenians by their ottoman rulers should be described as genocide.
1478 986 66 395 1570 1020 56 492 1328 621 1279 594 730 731 1131 513 330 360 786 1216 686 684 810 1387 519 873 250 763 57 1377 103 154 751 733 718 763 1427 858 690